Welcome to GuppyLog.com
New to Guppylog?
Immediate Help


Conversions and Calculator
Conversions and Tank volume calculator


Add yourself to our guppylog map
Guppylog Members


* Change as much water as often as you can! *
Inkmaker
Front Page · Everything · News · Ask Guppylog · Diaries
feeding "all natural" foods

All Topics
By Nancy4Fishes
from the Nancy4Fishes department, Section Ask Guppylog
Posted on Wed Aug 29, 2007 at 12:34:25 PM PST
Tags: (all tags)
 

   it's that time of year again! the birds are buzzing, the bees are singing...and the little buggies are popping up everywhere! question: is it safe to feed land bugs to aquarium fish?



   
   i know that mosquito larvae are great for fish, but what about the other little critters that we seem to never be free of during this season? for example: ants, flies, winged gnats (for small fry), mayflies, grown mosquitos, earthworms, etc.

   i remember watching my angelfish swallow a dead housefly as a first-year aquarist. only did it once, and it didn't harm the angel, but was it really wise?

   i always wanted to try to feed earthworms to my fish, but i never did. they seem like the perfect pathogen carriers. always in a warm, moist place. they produce plenty of waste in their slimecoat for the bacteria to eat. they would probably be a good protein source as a treat, if they were actually undiseased. if they were rinsed well, would they be safe?

  my house anually suffers an invasion from large black ants. i hate them so much. once i grabbed one and threw it in a still-hot toaster. usually i wash them down the drain. they would be much more useful if i could feed them to my fish, so could i? if they were rinsed, to get off dirt, maybe they would be OK?

  grown mosquitos may actually be a horrible idea for alot of people in areas with diseases that are carried by mosquitos, but for those of us that don't live in those areas, would they be all right?

  gnats can get to be a real problem here during june/august. they would be certainly hard to catch, but maybe if you were to slap one on your arm, you could just toss it in a fry tank? i don't think gnats really carry anything anyway.

  i know wild fish eat bugs in the water all the time, so is it really that bad of an idea? it sounds sketchy, but i can't think of any reason why not to. i know you people will have something up your sleeve for me, though. ;)

   i've only posted one other log, so i hope this is OK.

< Welcoming the bristlenoses home | Mysterious White Fungus or Bacteria? >
Menu

· create account

· F.A.Q. For Newbies!

· Immediate Help For Newbies!

· search


Web www.guppylog.com

· Scoop Info

· Our Tanks

Login
Make a new account
Username:
Password:

Related Links
· More on All Topics
· Also by Nancy4Fishes

Display: Sort:
feeding "all natural" foods | 15 comments (15 topical, editorial, 0 hidden)
(Comment Deleted) (none / 0) (#16)
by julio on Fri Dec 01, 2006 at 06:06:24 AM PST

This comment has been deleted by unclescott





(Comment Deleted) (none / 0) (#15)
by rossi on Thu Nov 02, 2006 at 01:03:10 AM PST

This comment has been deleted by unclescott





(Comment Deleted) (none / 0) (#14)
by rossi on Fri Oct 20, 2006 at 03:30:13 AM PST

This comment has been deleted by unclescott





thanks, everybody! (none / 0) (#9)
by Nancy4Fishes on Wed May 31, 2006 at 02:18:54 PM PST

 and i thought this wouldn't do well...anyway, with the bug season already nipping at our heels, i hope this is useful to someone. i know it is for me.



Re: thanks, everybody! (none / 0) (#13)
by RaiderFan92 on Sun Jun 04, 2006 at 05:22:31 PM PST

   I dont know if its good or not, but when I was about 5 I had a lizard that we feed live crickets. Every once in a while my dad would take a cricket out of my lizard's cage, plop it in the Jack Dimpsy tank, and enjoy the fishes at work!
"The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself."-FDR. True, unless your playing against the Oakland Raiders.
[ Parent ]


P.S. What would be an (none / 0) (#8)
by unclescott on Wed May 31, 2006 at 01:41:02 PM PST

"un-natural food?" :)



Re: feeding "all natural" foods (none / 0) (#4)
by Honeyrobber on Wed May 31, 2006 at 03:21:08 AM PST

 Short answer is yes fish can and do eat land loving critters even in the wild. Grasshoppers are a favorite food of many pond fish. There are exceptions though. One of those is many types of ants will not be eaten. They produce chemicals that repell attachers. I know your feeling of hatred for ants. We have those little black one so bad each time you set your drink down you have to look for ants before taking a drink. They do smell and taste bad as I got reminded earlier tonight when I forgot to look in my glass before taking a drink.

 I raise wingless fruit flies(aka gnats) to feed my fish. the fish love them. I will even explain a simple trap you can make to catch and feed these pesky critters to your fish. Take any bottle(2 liter, juice(32oz), ect.). Put a piece of an over ripe bannana in it and wait. When it gets a lot of gnats in it put the cap on it and stick it in the freezer. The gnats freeze and die or you can just chill them so they can not fly and sprinkle them on top of the water. If you freeze them thaw them before feeding. With the wingless ones I feed them alive since they can not fly and be a pest in the house.

  Earthworms are high in fats and protiens making them one of the best conditioning foods for breeding tropical fish. The only problem here is size of food and size of fish. For many fish like guppies they need to be rinsed and chopped into bite sized pieces. This does not bother me but many people it does. I also raise grindal worms which are a small version of earth worm which is white in color. No chopping required for guppies and that sized fish.

  Watch feeding to much live food as you can spoil your fish so they do not take flake food well. I got fish that have never seen flake food except as a gut load for grindal worms.

 A very easy food to raise that has not been mentioned that can even replace baby brine shrimp(BBS) is daphnia. Daphnia give live birth as long as the conditions are right and the new born daphnia are slightly larger the BBS. All I do during warm weather is take my water from partial water changes and put it outside in the sun. The water turns green. I then pour this water into the daphnia tank sitting outside in the sun. You will not get many mossy larva this way due to the water getting hot and the bright light but I do catch a few. Then use a BBS net to catch some for your fish. One reason for letting the water turn green first is I strain it to collect and mossy larva before they can develope. If the daphnia culture is strong there will not be many mossy larva and when I do scoop out some daphnia I try and catch all the comma shaped ones I see. Indoor culture is not much different with descent lighting but tends to be slower on producing green water. So I have to feed then some yeast that has been activated in warm water. It does not take many to make millions. All of them are females as long as the conditions are good and all produce clones. The give birth to 4-22 live female daphnia every 4 days and it takes them only a week to become mature. Their live cycle is sort of like brine shrimp as they also produce a resting egg(cyst) when either their pool is drying up or the food runs low by producing males and laying eggs.

 All bugs that fish will eat that I have tried have cause no problems. Some say do not feed any kind of beetle. But there is a small beetle that my fish have eaten and nothing happened. Some beetles though are like some ants and use chemical warfare to keep from being eaten and I a sure the larger ones may have thick enough shells to cause problems.

 I feel all should feed their fish live foods but since I can not change everyone I suggest you feed flake food along with live foods so that all fish you sell/give/trade will eat flake foods for their new owners.

                        Later, John Cox
John Cox of Cumberland Killies and bee services



Re: feeding "all natural" foods (none / 0) (#6)
by angelhologram on Wed May 31, 2006 at 11:57:42 AM PST

Your suggestions on forming greenwater are easy to understand and much appreciated! As I had discussed with Uncle Scott before I have the problem of no greenwater when I want it and a pond full when I don't. I'll try your methods and if I can produce greenwater consistantly I can then move on to the next step of aquiring daphnia. Thank you very much for the information.  ~Shell
*BEFORE you buy fish make sure you understand what "Cycling" a tank means <- quoted from miskaral* ~Trying to make a difference one fish at a time~
[ Parent ]


Thank you John! (none / 0) (#5)
by unclescott on Wed May 31, 2006 at 03:27:25 AM PST

I thought I recognized your e-mail addy from KT!

all the best!
uncle scott

[ Parent ]



Re: feeding "all natural" foods (none / 0) (#2)
by lomelindi on Wed May 31, 2006 at 03:11:24 AM PST

Leaving the definitive answers to the old pros as usual, but I'd like to offer that I tried offering one of those little black ants to one of my bettas ages ago, and he was utterly disgusted with it.  He swallowed it then immediately spit it back out.  And stared at me like I'd been trying to kill him.  I felt it necessary to apologize. x.x



Ants often have a acidic taste which causes fish (none / 0) (#3)
by unclescott on Wed May 31, 2006 at 03:19:34 AM PST

to spit them out. Some of the books allude to ants which fall in the water of African brooks. Either they are very different tasting species from most American ants or the fish are starving or the authors were confusing them with termites, which (even though we don't want them in our homes) are very significant ecologically for their ability to turn a lot of wood and cellulose into protein. They are a big part of the food web in several places.

More (yawn) later... :)

unc

[ Parent ]



Re: feeding "all natural" foods (none / 0) (#1)
by miskairal on Wed May 31, 2006 at 12:06:14 AM PST

What a great question!
Everyone else must have thought so too as it's through to the Front page without my even seeing it in the queue.

Hoping someone can answer this as I sure can't.
--
Repeat after me,
I will read the Immediate Help



Different strokes for different folks! (none / 0) (#10)
by unclescott on Wed May 31, 2006 at 06:17:54 PM PST

Great question Nancy! And your seasonal timing is most appropriate!

Lomelindi, there are no pros on this site, though John is getting awfully close. You will have to settle for answers from (more or less) experienced hobbyists. :)

There are a number of things "round and about" which we could feed our fish and increase the variety and nutrition of their foods. Stuff raised outdoors does seem to have more vitamins, and maybe more trace elements and nutrients. Aquarists have often noticed better color on fish raised outside or, to a degree, fed foods from outside.

There are some limits. I wouldn't use worms if the homes nearby or uphill use insecticides or herbicides on the lawn. (Remember those cute, little, lawn care trucks?) If a nearby family sprays for anything, be reluctant collecting anything.

One of the best things to do to raise worms outdoors is just to make a compost pile. All sorts of yard and kitchen (vegetable scraps) can be worked in. I'll probably dig a few worms up this afternoon while doing garden stuff. A few will get tossed in a cup, "for later".

An increasing number of advanced aquarists are raising some sort of worm. See John's comments for why.

If one does an on-line search for Vermiculture or worm culture, they will get a lot of hits. To my surprise, I also found a couple of books on raising earthworms in our public library.

The African redworm is popular with aquarists indoors because it and the smaller grindle worm grow fairly well at room temperature. There are a couple of earthworms cultured that way. One of them is also called a manure worm and if raised on manure, are not attractive to fish. But fed on kitchen scraps, alkaline leaves and the like, they are really appreciated by fish. On behalf of my killifish club, I even order a big bag of Purina Worm Chow.

Worms do need space, food and moisture, but not flooding. We had a great program, a while back, by a guy from Indianapolis (his initials are Al Anderson) who uses three old 55-gallon aquariums to co-culture redworms and Grindleworms. He harvests a cup or two of them every second day. There are also patterns for untreated, wooden boxes, which are even vented so the worms don't drown or cook. One does need room to raise them and must be patient while the cultures build. (If you have barracks style stands, worm boxes can be slipped underneath.)

The worm farm sites will want to sell you all sorts of gear. It's nice but not always necessary. A wooden box or some sort of (food quality?) bin which will not poison the worms, a bunch of chopped/ cut up cardboard or white newspaper for bedding, the worm food and patience, are pretty much what you need.

I don't raise them because ours is a slab foundation and it gets pretty warm in the summer and very dry in the winter. (And I can be a lazy bum.) By summer I'm raising really more Daphnia than I can use, outdoors. There are bloodworms now, earlier than usual. If I am not careful, there can be mosquitoes, so a special effort is made to harvest them (sometimes returning the Daphnia to that container to eat the mossie larvae just hatching from their eggs).

We have kidded here about "If a fish can fit into the mouth of another, it will." (Not so funny if you are the smaller fish.)

That also applied for bugs. Guppies are so small that what is raised in the culture barrels out back works better for them. I wonder if the more compact larvae actually have more food value anyway. Smacked adult mossies are relished by larger fishes able to swallow them. The rainbow fish will pick them off of the surface at full speed.

But you've noticed that your angelfish and others with larger mouths will go for larger food. Years ago my Dad re-lined my old (fishing) landing net with material from some sheer curtains. I think he used it to get cats out of trees. ;)

One of the days I'll take that to the field down the block and around the corner and run back and forth like an idiot, waving it. There are a lot of flies and gnats which are small enough for some of the fish to eat. Still don't know about the guppies though. There may be some small fly and gnat species which would fill the bill.

John's net in the freezer is probably the best way to slow them down. A friend of mine found some fruit flies circling some "mature" fruit in the house. He grabbed a little bit of a fine-meshed cloth, pushed it into the wand of his vacuum cleaner and sucked up the little beggars. He also quickly tied the ends of the cloth together and placed the bundle in the freezer.

Since it would take quite a cord to hook up to a dorm refrigerator dragged down the couple of blocks to that field, I'll probably settle for my fish room soup pot, with the lid and fairly full load of water. A clear plastic food storage box with a tight lid might work too. Probably have to rescue some butterflies.

I wonder how hard it would be to make small fly traps which could easily be tossed into the freezer? Googling [live fly traps] gets almost 7 million hits. Googling "fly traps" gets a mere 172,000 hits.

One of the NANFA posts, a while back, told of a person with some fish in a tub in his back yard. He also had a bugwhacker. The tub was settled under the bugwhacker and the crispy critters fell to the sunfish below.

"Back when" we were camping at Ohio's Guilford Lake State Park or something of the sort. The guy next to me was doing very well catching and releasing crappies. I asked him, as he was packing up, what he was using. Turns out he was using fly maggots, which were kept in flour.

Poultry keepers and other will keep a little over-ripe meat hanging way up, out of the way, on a string (outside). The flies will "blow" their eggs into the meat (hence, blowflies). The eggs hatch and the larvae or maggots will drop to the meal in a tray below. In some cases the poultry just eat the grubs there.

That guy in Ohio gave me his extras and after I got over my squeamishness, they worked pretty well as bait. They were so full of flour, there wasn't much disagreeable about them.

However if you Google "raising fly maggots for fishing" you will get a bunch of hits on places which do just that. They sell to fishermen and the pet industry for birds and reptiles. (I just want to see the "round-up" on a worm ranch!)

There were a bunch of maggots in the garbage this morning. Ytech! I carried the bag, at arm's length, out to the street as quickly as I could. Upon returning to the carport, I noticed a number of maggots stuck to the top of the can. That was tossed over in the yard, for the small birds to browse upon.

About an hour later, I happened by. There were fewer maggots, but what was left seemed fairly clean. The garbage can lid  was gingerly picked up and taken back to where two more or less 20-gallon containers of Fundulus were. Those Fundulus, aware of the nocturnal traffic of varmints, primarily raccoons, but also with a few 'possums and skunks (mostly there to make unc walk verrrrry carefully in the dark) and the early morning visits by a gray fox, have learned to make themselves pretty scarce. Tipping the can lid so a few maggots dropped into the water, pulled Fundulus from their hiding places to snap them up. The rest of the maggots were dropped in. As of a few minutes ago, they were all gone.

Once had a crazy male BDR (Big Dumb Rivulus), a 3+ inch male Rivulus amphoreus. He was a widower, through no fault of his own. When his female was lost, he was demoted from his 15-gallon tank to a thin-necked gallon apple cider jug. I noticed that he would enthusiastically jump up the bottle neck to take flake food from my hand. Next came small spiders, caught hanging from their guy-lines. A small selection of twigs were laid in and once in a while, one of those guy-lines was intercepted and the spider lowered into the lair of the Rivulus, by then known as "Animal". He would erupt from the water. Sometimes he got the spider first try. Many times they were both knocked silly. Despite earning few "style points" Animal would perform upon demand and locally became a bit of a fishy celebrity. In his own bowl for a general club fish show, I has to chase a buddy of mine away from him, since my friend was gently tapping the tightly stretched plastic wrap (secured around the drum bowl top with a rubber band). After 20-25 jumps out of the water, I felt that was enough. I was pleased when that (rather attractive little gray ditch) fish took Reserve Best of Show to a gaudy and monstrous Central American cichlid.

Animal wouldn't take any of those big black carpenter ants either. Those ants can be bad news for the house and in time I left the spiders alone, because at least in the winter, a pretty good fishroom population of spiders kept the ants at bay without seeming to bother the fish.

Because of the seasonal heat in the house and the space needed to raise worms, I have found it time effective and maybe money effective to buy a couple portions of blackworms from "my" LFS. They last a long time in their blue worm holders, which are slipped in unobtrusively under the refrigerator cold-cut drawer, where only the nosiest visitor would ever find them. ;)

This comment is becoming something of an all day project, as the need to run errands, be taken by the schnoodle for a walk, and other things keep interfering. As I was typing this, the thought blackworms! came to mind. With the abundance from the Daphnia tubs, the distraction of the wedding and all the logistics that involved, the worms, which should be rinsed every couple of days, have been ignored for a couple of weeks.

There are a few dead worms (less than .1% of them) and some dirt (worm castings?) in those worm trays. But they are rinsing off nicely. It is a good idea to gently rinse them a couple of times and leave them sit, so their systems are purged and addition debris is shaken free by the healthy blackworms. Then rinse again.

Some people have had trouble rinsing blackworms in chloramines and heavy chlorine. They will even have to store treated rinsing water in the refrigerator, near the worms.  Our water must not have chlorine applied at such a critical level and the worms, fortunately, do fine.

That availability of the worms illustrates another likely hood in feeding fish or even in supplementing their flake food diet. We are usually only going to feed what is most convenient for us. Once in a while I will drop a few crushed half peas for the live bearers and break up a few pieces of Freeze Dried Plankton for the larger fishes. But those things are for novelty, even if really appreciated by the fish.

Another interruption in commenting here was a trip to the "back 40" when the sun was high in the sky, for visibility's sake. The stroll was made with two pint jars of greenwater, a fine-meshed net about 10"/ 25 cm across and the schnoodle, who hopped up onto the chaise lounge, from where he could supervise. ;)

I took a healthy scoop from each of a couple of Daphnia vats-barrels-32-gallon garbage cans. The nets were emptied in the greenwater jars. Those were then taken back indoors and stowed in the refrigerator. That will slow down their development and metabolism - just as some of us do with live brine shrimp. They will remain healthy, as opposed to suffocating, until I get around to feeding them tonight. The greenwater, by the way, will all be strained out by then. (Actually it was within an hour!)

The number of Daphnia outside will be replaced by the time they are harvested again. Actually if they were harvested more often, there would be room for more small Daphnia for the small fry.

The leaf litter in them largely fuels the barrel cultures outside. That also explains the abundance not only of Daphnia but also of Ostrocods and some bloodworms. With the recent rains, three inches of water was taken from them in the course of harvesting. An inch of greenwater was gently poured back in each container.

John's use of dissolved yeast along with greenwater is a dynamite feeding combination. He has evidently mastered dissolving a little bit in warm water and then adding water until it is just lightly tinted. The experimenters reporting in Needham, et al's Laboratory Culture of Invertebrate Animals (Dover Press reprint about 1962) highly recommended those two foods as the best for Daphnia.

I don't use yeast because I am a klutz and if a clumsy person over-feeds the yeast, the water will become short of oxygen and all of the Daphnia will die. Right now they are so prolific as is, I don't need more Daphnia! (And must start doing more water changes if the fish ever eat all of the Daphnia in their tanks.)

Likewise I will not put a bugwhacker above a pool of fish, even if I kept fish large enough to crunch down roasted June bugs. That Klutz and lazy factor again - I'd probably electrocute myself. ;)

All the best!
unc

P.S. What would be an "un-natural food"?  :)


[ Parent ]



Re: live food another ramble (none / 0) (#11)
by Honeyrobber on Wed May 31, 2006 at 08:52:58 PM PST

 First off no pro here. I have had killies just over a year and learned much from killietalk and other email list I am on. I then in turn tell other what I have learned.

 Daphnia are real new to me culturing them. I collected them out of the river many times and fed them to my fish over the years but never heard of them being grown indoors to feed fish during the winter until I was around killie people. I actually feed my daphnia a mix of foods that I got from several different people. On the yeast I learned real quick about feeding to much. I did as I was told on KT(killietalk). I put 1/2 a teaspoon of yeast in 6 oz of warm water. Let it soak a bit and then stir it up. I am glad I split the culture the day before. After it was well mixed I dumped this yeast water in one of the cultures and then rinsed it into the other one as it was still cold weather and the indoor green water cultures where not producing enough to keep the cultures fed. The one I fed died out completely. The one I rinsed the cup in did good. So the next time I mixed it like I was told and instead of giving the whole thing to the daphnia I gave both cultures a squirt of this mixture from my turkey baster. It was amazing how quickly they cleared this cloud up. So I gave them more. I continued to give them more of this through out the day. I ended up giving them the whole cupful of yeast water through out the day. After this it has been smooth sailing. I feed baby food sweet potatoes and peas from time to time and freeze unused portions for later dates. I also mix some paparika in with the yeast mixture after doing a lot of internet research. Paparika is full of vitamins. I now give the outside cultures some yeast from time to time to boost production over the green water(it is still the weekest link in this food chain).

  Like all of yall other hobbiest I still make mistakes. But I just try to learn from my mistakes. One thing I learned early on was how much better growing fish outside was over tank raised fish. I think it is a combination of UV light(suntan anyone), live food, and plenty of space for growth. They have great color and size and health. Well now I am getting close to those results growing fish indoors with live food and good florescent lighting(it produces some UV).

  Live foods are the main key to raising fish unlike you have never seen before. I have fish which have never seen flake food and are better looking and bigger that the parents ever got that were fed flake food and live foods. I am not real big on "clean" tanks either. I do my water changes and syphon the stuff off the bottom weekly if not more often but I do not clean my tanks until I can not see through the glass. I let algea grow and such. I learned a long time ago spotless tanks are not actually very healthy a lot of the time. Sometimes what you percieve as a nasty fish tank is a very healthy inviroment. The streams our beloved fish come from have algea and plants and bugs and much more that many of you would hate to see in your tanks. Life is messy, make mud pies, LOL.

 
John Cox of Cumberland Killies and bee services
[ Parent ]



Re: live food another ramble (none / 0) (#12)
by Nancy4Fishes on Thu Jun 01, 2006 at 04:06:57 PM PST

yes, i've tried brine shrimp cultures before, but the eggs i bought were invalid and out of date. i just recently bought a "sea monkey" kit. they seem like alot of fun, and breed by themsleves. they grow to be a bit bigger than regular brines, so i figure i'll use the eggs in the starter pack to grow adults. after 3-4 weeks, i'll have some babies from them. then, i take a few babies a day from the little sea monkey container (it holds about 10 oz of water)and feed them to my betta, and any fry i have around. excess adults could probably be eaten by the 2 inch betta too, but the adults are anywhere from 1/2 to 3/4 of an inch!

   anyway, i just hope this starts a successful culture. i just added the egg packet today (saving about 25% of the eggs in case something goes wrong before they can reproduce). there is an instruction packet, as well as a company website (sea-monkeys.com) with a faq section, so maybe these things might actually live.

[ Parent ]



feeding "all natural" foods | 15 comments (15 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
Display: Sort:

SourceForge Logo Powered by Scoop
Subscribe to our news feed
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest © 2002 and beyond The Management

create account | faq | search